It is a pleasure to break a frozen silence with good news. In a world filled with hatred, news of love spread only slowly, and resistance against the cold that surrounds us is difficult to maintain for long. This is the reason why Muse come to us so very welcome with their new album, The Resistance. What they bring is not simply a collection of songs, but a philosophy that resists the hatred and the coldness it carries.
“Tell me the things you hate, and I will tell you who you are.” That’s a saying I have heard often, too often perhaps. These days, people tend to define themselves by, through and with the things they hate and fear. Those can include anyone and anything: coffee, strawberries, milk, hippies, the Arabs, the Americans, metal music, jazz music, pop music, science fiction, postmodernism, chick lit, comedy, feminism, machismo, the Jews, the black people, the Chinese, the Europeans, soldiers, pacifists, neo-Nazis, neo-Marxists, eggs and eggplants, open shirts and leather jeans, the cities and the mountains, the strong communities and the strong individuals, capitalism and communism, the cold air and the hot air and the salt waters and the noisy rivers and the computers and the calculators and the children and the old people and the sunshine and the night-time and the rain and ourselves. Loathing has become something of a way of life. The question of whom and what we love is lost amidst all this roaring hatership. Not that hatred and fear are feelings unnatural and completely alien to us humans; no, but they are taken as the one, singular way of experiencing things, as the truly visceral and most powerful manner of relating to reality. When faced with these tidal waves of scorn, one wonders where to go, what to do, and how to resist.
It all starts with an uprising. Going against hatred means saying no to it, it means putting an end to cold exploitation – even through strength, if need be: “Rise up and take the power back / It’s time the fat cats had a heart attack” (“Uprising”). What one must never forget, though, is that any battle against oppression is a fight for truth, justice, for equality and love. That kind of struggle always reaches an end, unlike the struggle for power. The power-hungry can never be full; and those who do not believe me should re-read Orwell’s 1984. Intentionally or not, Muse’s music and especially lyrics seem to relate to that conveniently forgotten book. They act in a starkly subversive manner and regularly bring together the need to fight with the need for justice:
“I’m hungry for some unrest
I wanna push it beyond a peaceful protest
I wanna speak in a language that they will understand
Dedication to a new age
This is the end of destruction and rampage
Another chance to raise and never plead again
Counter balance this commotion
We’re not droplets in the ocean” (“Unnatural Selection”)
There is, however, one very specific and central thought to these combative moods. It’s short and simple, and it goes like this: “Love is our resistance” (“Resistance”). The truth is very brief, as one famous character from The Name of the Rose would have it, and lends itself to almost immediate comprehension; one just has to see, hear, read it. This plain statement of intent, truth and philosophy rightfully belongs to the beginning of a story, and that is where Muse have put it.
From a musical viewpoint, it remains blessedly difficult to put Muse into one category: the band show too many different faces on an album of medium length. One thing I see in their manner of composing and playing is the spirit of a Queen reborn. Just like the older fellow countrymen of theirs, Muse tend to explode into symphonicity, bombastic choruses, and soaring harmonies. Another feature the two bands can be said to share is the enormous amount of reverb and sheer space with which they build their songs. Just remember “Innuendo” and compare it to, say, “Resistance”, “Guiding Light”, or “Exogenesis: Symphony”. They want you to turn the volume up and up and up to get closer to the actual notes, beats, and words, and in the process to help erect cathedrals and ziggurats of resplendent melodies in front of yourself. Finally, just think for a minute: how often do we meet excellent singers who also happen to be extremely proficient on both the piano and the guitar? The comparisons, however, end here. Muse, as mentioned, incorporate a huge number of musical knacks, tricks and licks borrowed from a range of bands like Genesis or Yes to a whole row of 80’s groups (a list of which will perhaps be several times longer than the list of things people hate that I conjured up on the fly above). Last but certainly not least, they are themselves throughout. Precise, surprisingly flourishing, and sublimely titanic drumming; profoundly expressive bass (see “Resistance” again – no other comments) that one often mistakes for synths and even guitars; as well as floods of piano and orchestration, especially in the closing “Exogenesis: Symphony”. Bellamy’s guitar has been put to the side for some of the duration, or tends to lurk low in the harmonical edifice, but never fails to come to the fore at the very right moments in “Resistance”, “Unnatural Selection” and “Guiding Light”. The trio constantly show love for the music they create, and for the listener it is intended for.
Many are the depictions of love that can fit on that modern piece of technology we call a CD, and the more skillful the people who paint those portraits, the more truthful, diverse and vivid they become. One thing Muse cannot allow themselves to do, nonetheless, is paint love blind, or turn it into a blanket but blank emotion that is supposed to cover everyone and everything. Love is no carpet under which you can sweep all your emotional luggage. It is a living thing that gives you life and always breathes back into your lungs the force you put into it, but it is also something mortal. As we build monuments to those truly good among us who have died, so do Muse to love in their world-shattering and primordial “Guiding Light”:
“Impure hearts stumble
In my hands they crumble
And fragile and stripped to the core
I can’t hurt you anymore
Loved by numbers
You’re losing life’s wonder
Touch like strangers detached
I can’t feel you anymore”
When the cold numbers outnumber the heartbeats of love and the sunshine inside is crushed by that ultimate freeze, love dies; its guiding light vanishes. Such is the colossal force of this cosmic death that it remains only barely describable. Even when love returns in the new form – in “I Belong to You” – of an appropriately named “guiding lightning strike”, its presence retains the sinister quality of a possible vanishing; in the song, that is indicated by Muse’s version of the aria “Mon Coeur S’ouvre A Ta Voix” from Saint-Saens’s Samson and Delilah, embedded into the piece as a song-within-the-song. Such ominous moments can be experienced on several occasions: in “United States of Eurasia”, where the protagonist dreams of a united Eurasia, but that always entails “Collateral Damage”; in “MK Ultra”, where things are slipping out of control (“How much deception can you take? / How many lies will you create?”) while Bellamy’s guitar meets an orchestra and the two stroll away hand-in-hand with the listener; and in the grandeur of the closing “Exogenesis: Symphony”.
I am not wading knee-deep into the vast oceans of orchestration on a daily basis, but this three-part piece slowly and infallibly ensnared me with its electro-magnetic flow. And if what it says is true – that we have failed this planet, that we have already forfeited all our chances to preserve life on it and must begin a centuries-slow, womb-to-tomb migration to stars so incredibly far – then it says it with a gentle hope, and a wide-eyed, tearful, shivering optimism.
The end of the music at this point seems to signal the end of a world, and one is left in the uneasy silence with too many questions. A handful of things are clear for the free-thinking person: that one can be sure the fight continues; that love is the unifier, and with it comes a pervasive but not blind optimism, and a knowledge that truths, all truths, must always be kept close. We should probably learn at least this from Muse: to speak in the future simple tense when fighting for the future, to remember the truth of oppression and exploitation, and to know that love is the mightiest power of resistance.